This is a world constantly on the edge of war, and thinking of war with the “Buggers”, who have come close to destroying Earth a few times before. In the search for a new savior, the army stumbles across Ender, an 11 year old from a small town in America that is never revealed. As he grows into what they hope will become the savior of Earth against the enemy, we follow his journey. If you read the first review, you know I feel this book cannot live up to it’s potential set up by the plot and characters. After reading some more of this book, I'm sad to say that the book has not improved. The novel still suffers from the same shortcomings and pitfalls that plagued it before, and does not seem to be heading into a better direction.
After the first review, the book seemed to pick up for a while. I was
excited as Ender seemed to be growing as a character and the characters around him seemed to be more fleshed out and be very human. However, this section of the book is short lived, and we are met with more paper thin characters that are cold and not relatable. One example of these cold characters come where Ender is striving with his suit, and the leader of the group berates the rest of the boys, saying “" 'Why weren't you ready?' asked Dap. 'you had your suits just as long as they did.'" (61) Ender once again becomes cold and shut off, and the book slows down again. The best example of Ender’s cold lifeless attitude come when the book says "Knocking him down won the first fight. I wanted to win all the next ones, too. So they'd leave me alone." (16) The development of previous characters is almost non existent, and makes it very difficult to get invested in the book, or any of it’s characters. Every time there seems to be a promising plot point, or a character that could become one of some substance, they are immediately swept to the side, and replaced with more cold, lifeless versions of the same generic character types found in many science fiction novels. Also, as opposed to making their disappearance have an impact on Ender, changing his character and making him feel more human, they are instead left behind, never to be mentioned again. This cycle is very annoying and leaves much to be desired from the novel and its writer.
The positives, that are few and far between, remain mainly the same from
my first take on the novel. The book still does not stray far off the path it has set for itself, for better or for worse. The action and battle scenes remain the most interesting and best written part of the book, with their vivid descriptions painting mental pictures of chaos, but still being clear and precise enough so you can keep track of all important moments and characters through the chaos. Dialogue between the characters has become more and more forced, but still remains somewhat believable, giving the characters their only real humanity. The premise of the novel remains the same, thus remaining as interesting as in the beginning. There are a few human moments, one of which comes early in Ender’s stay at Battle School, where "...His desk would go dark, 'Free Play Over' would march around the desk, and Ender would lie back and tremble until he could finally go to sleep." (64) However, for all these positives, the negatives still manage to drag the book down.
As you maybe can tell from these past two reviews, I'm not this book’s
biggest fan. However, I could see this book appealing to someone who wants a good science fiction book to read with lots of action and not much else. Though I may not finish the book, if it sounds like something that you would like, I definitely recommend it to you.